It's Complicated ** two stars (two stars out of 5)
we need better romantic comedies we need better romantic comedies we need better romantic comedies we need better romantic comedies
You might ask yourself: "
Why is life so complicated"? Well on a New Years day, circa 2009, I took myself to see It's Complicated, possibly to see if it could explain. Also with not much out there in the theater to see or clamor for, and wanting to take in something light and funny, and the fact that Steve Martin hasn't been in anything for a long time. All these are good reasons, though, not good enough to justify this movie.
It's Complicated never does end up answering the question, unless it is to point out that with the right table settings, and the perfect clean house, everything in your life is bound to go right. Keep shopping and perfection is near.
I have to say I hated director Nancy Meyers' last -perfect kitchen and house and trimmings - movie something fierce. Something's Gotta Give was appallingly bad. With both movies she somehow found a great group of actors to fill the parts. Something's Gotta Give was weak, over the top smarmy, and just plain garbage.
Enter It's Complicated at the end of 2009. After giving us a few years break from her brand of humor, Nancy comes back with another Romance fest. From the outside it looks like it could be fun. From the inside, in the theater, it was a selfish, over-indulged, exaggerated wanna be Martha Stewart, designer movie.
It's as if she can't quite figure out what she really wants to do. Be a home decorator, or make a movie. She does like to point out two things she consistently feels strongly about though, and believes we should all agree:
A. You are a loser old bag if you are a single woman and aren't agonizing over some man who doesn't treat you right, but one day will, if only you do and say the right thing. You may have to beat him into submission with your overflowing enthusiasm, physchoticness, neediness, and utter lack of self esteem, while forcing him to tip toe through your sanitized and trimmed house. Eventually, if you do it all just right, he will Love You!
B. That the world is ok, even if you don't feel like it right now, as long as you have spent a small kings fortune on making your house, yard, kids, and business (which also should just happen to be a FABULOUS hip bakery) absolutely perfect. If you have every correct plate, silverware, all the perfect do dads to fill your house, your children have just right clothes, etc, then the rest of your life must be great. I felt like I was stuck watching 2 hours of a Dramedy HGTV show, without having someone to tell us how they did it all (we can wait for that to be explained on the DVD special features). It really is one of those things that drives me bonkers. America is so obsessed with having their house, and clothes, and yard and cars and CHILDREN be so perfect and tidy, that onlookers will gush at your spectaculourness. Ugh. What is lost is a sense of things being alive. Everything is plastic, magazine clean, mirages of reality.
Sadly, Steve Martin seemed to be just standing in for his part. Almost as if someone had dropped out and they asked him to fill in on that day. No Martin zeal or humor. Almost drugged.
Meryl Streep was great, though she overplayed some of it. Alec Baldwin was fantastic, and the kids dutifully did their parts.
It was a mishmash of not much. A few funnies, a few heavies, but in the end, none of it memorable enough to conjure up in my head two days later.
I am the worlds biggest Romantic Comedy fan, and I keep trying them out, hoping for good things. I consistently end up screaming: Where oh where is another WHEN HARRY MET SALLY when you need one! It's been over 10 years now, and Nothing. Not a single movie has come close. When Harry met Sally is the perfect Rom-Com. SAY ANYTHING was fantastic, but it came out the same year too. That's ten years of dull.
All things considered, this movie was a lazy
** two stars out of five.
Rental: still
** two stars
Redbox: still
** two stars
2009 was the year of dreck. I hope 2010 can start the good vibe movie engines again. Here's hopin'.